Physical and social conditions in the Middle Ages certainly reinforced magical thinking. But are people much different today?
Most of us are still illiterate, especially in the languages of science and technology, but also in economics, psychology, and even history and geography. We crave mystical leaders and put unquestioned faith in preferred narratives, supported by semi-fictional media. We imagine endless apocalyptic scenarios that justify delusional visions that we seek to impose on others. And, of course, some of us take advantage of these human tendencies to control us and advance their own agenda.
Perhaps we are doomed to magical thinking until (if?) some post-human brain evolves.
My grandfather, orphaned as a baby when his parents died in steerage on an immigrant ship, was raised in a religious orphanage. He might disagree with you. So might the numbers of people who have benefited from the Salvation Army, or who have been cared for at the 624 Catholic hospitals and 499 Catholic longterm care facilities in the USA (unfortunately the Salvation Army closed its last hospital decades ago - I had the privilege of working at a Salvation Army hospital and was truly impressed by how it was run). So might the women cared for in homes for unwed mothers, usually run by religious institutions. So might the recipients worldwide who benefit from the Catholic Relief Fund. As for myself, I graduated first in my Medical School class and first in the college of science in undergrad at Notre Dame, which success I attribute to the strict academic rigor of parochial grade and high school. Today, where public schools just received a terrible "report card" from the NAEP, the parochial schools performed much better and for 1/3 the cost per student compared to the public sector. In many congregations people get enormous support from their religious community in tough times - as my brother did when he was ill and finally died from pancreatic cancer. I am no longer religious and agree that almost all religions are capable of being perverted by some people, but a rational person would also admit the good that is also being done by many religious people.
Composer Robert Schumann travelled up the Rhine with his wife Clara to see the installation of a new cardinal. The fourth movement of his third symphony, known as the Rhenish, is a tribute to the cathedral.
Excellent article, Michael. The fertile ground for religion and other superstition is the lack of control or the perceived lack of control over the events in our surroundings, especially harmful events.
I am annoyed with people imposing their magical thinking onto me. When I have been ill, religious friends have proclaimed they will pray for me, even to the extent of putting my name on their weekly list of prayers to a specific saint (Catholic ). They seem to actually believe that "sending" their thoughts to Nobody is going to help Me. : O. One woman was alarmed that she hadn't known I had been ill. She said "if I had only known you were sick, I would have prayed for you" : O. This is weird on so many levels.
if Europe is conquered by Islam as it was conquered by Christianity we can expect another dark age..... now the best part of Christianity was probably what Christianity needed to assimilate from the Europeans in order to convince them of the value of this new religion... Christianity brought the fear of god and the worthlessness of man into society and through fear and superstition was able to control the population while making some very rich and others very poor.
Physical and social conditions in the Middle Ages certainly reinforced magical thinking. But are people much different today?
Most of us are still illiterate, especially in the languages of science and technology, but also in economics, psychology, and even history and geography. We crave mystical leaders and put unquestioned faith in preferred narratives, supported by semi-fictional media. We imagine endless apocalyptic scenarios that justify delusional visions that we seek to impose on others. And, of course, some of us take advantage of these human tendencies to control us and advance their own agenda.
Perhaps we are doomed to magical thinking until (if?) some post-human brain evolves.
modern myths are supported by modern advances in technology and improved lifestyles
As I've said before, there are only three positive things the Christian religion has contributed to mankind - Architecture, Art and Music.
My grandfather, orphaned as a baby when his parents died in steerage on an immigrant ship, was raised in a religious orphanage. He might disagree with you. So might the numbers of people who have benefited from the Salvation Army, or who have been cared for at the 624 Catholic hospitals and 499 Catholic longterm care facilities in the USA (unfortunately the Salvation Army closed its last hospital decades ago - I had the privilege of working at a Salvation Army hospital and was truly impressed by how it was run). So might the women cared for in homes for unwed mothers, usually run by religious institutions. So might the recipients worldwide who benefit from the Catholic Relief Fund. As for myself, I graduated first in my Medical School class and first in the college of science in undergrad at Notre Dame, which success I attribute to the strict academic rigor of parochial grade and high school. Today, where public schools just received a terrible "report card" from the NAEP, the parochial schools performed much better and for 1/3 the cost per student compared to the public sector. In many congregations people get enormous support from their religious community in tough times - as my brother did when he was ill and finally died from pancreatic cancer. I am no longer religious and agree that almost all religions are capable of being perverted by some people, but a rational person would also admit the good that is also being done by many religious people.
Monogamy.
and celibacy for the very best and brightest... a good program to reduce overall intelligence
Fantastic essay Michael, great way to enter into your second year on Substack.
"On this latest visit I noticed that... , modern eyes in the sky have been added, just in case..." That's part funny and profound. A lovely essay.
Composer Robert Schumann travelled up the Rhine with his wife Clara to see the installation of a new cardinal. The fourth movement of his third symphony, known as the Rhenish, is a tribute to the cathedral.
Excellent article, Michael. The fertile ground for religion and other superstition is the lack of control or the perceived lack of control over the events in our surroundings, especially harmful events.
I am annoyed with people imposing their magical thinking onto me. When I have been ill, religious friends have proclaimed they will pray for me, even to the extent of putting my name on their weekly list of prayers to a specific saint (Catholic ). They seem to actually believe that "sending" their thoughts to Nobody is going to help Me. : O. One woman was alarmed that she hadn't known I had been ill. She said "if I had only known you were sick, I would have prayed for you" : O. This is weird on so many levels.
if Europe is conquered by Islam as it was conquered by Christianity we can expect another dark age..... now the best part of Christianity was probably what Christianity needed to assimilate from the Europeans in order to convince them of the value of this new religion... Christianity brought the fear of god and the worthlessness of man into society and through fear and superstition was able to control the population while making some very rich and others very poor.